USA « North Korean Economy Watch

Archive for the ‘USA’ Category

DPRK government denied banking services in Kaesong (Updated)

Tuesday, September 19th, 2006

From the Joong Ang Daily:
9/21/2006
Lee Young-jong

Contrary to its statement on Tuesday, the Unification Ministry pressured Woori Bank to consider allowing North Korea to open a bank account, government documents obtained by a Grand National Party lawmaker showed yesterday.

A Unification Ministry official who asked not to be named said it was just a discussion and not formal pressure against the bank. He said the bank made its own decision, without being pressured by the ministry.

Representative Kwon Young-se obtained a copy of correspondence that the Unification Ministry sent to Woori Bank on March 28, and provided it to the JoongAng Ilbo.

According to the letter, the ministry tried to stretch the laws governing inter-Korean projects to grant the North’s wish. The North, in September of last year, asked the bank, which operates a branch in Kaesong Industrial Complex, to open an account under the name of the Kaesong Industrial District Management Committee, headed by a South Korean official. The bank informed the Unification Ministry and consulted with it.

“The committee is composed of South Korean members, thus opening the account under its name is within the scope of approved inter-Korean cooperation projects,” the ministry told the bank in the letter.

The committee, however, is a North Korean corporation established under North Korean laws. Contrary to the ministry’s claim, North Korean officials are also working there.

Minutes of a meeting on March 7, where government officials discussed the issue, were also provided to the JoongAng Ilbo, showing the Unification Ministry apparently pressured the bank despite objections from other ministries. “We urge the bank to make a wise decision,” the ministry said, according to the minutes.

The bank, however, was opposed to opening an account for North Korea, citing South Korea’s financial laws and the U.S. Treasury Department’s anti-terror law. The bank also cited expected opposition from the Financial Action Task Force on Money Laundering in turning down the North’s request, the minutes said.

From Yonhap:
N. Korean request to open account with S. Korean bank in Kaesong rejected
Byun Duk-kun
9/19/2006

North Korea sought to open an account with a South Korean bank at an inter-Korean industrial complex in its border town of Kaesong last year, but the South Korean bank rejected the request, officials at the Unification Ministry said Tuesday.

The report comes amid U.S. financial sanctions against the communist state for its alleged involvement in illegal activities, including counterfeiting, laundering and the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction.

Ministry officials, however, dismissed suspicions that North Korea may have tried to use the South Korean bank to evade, or find a safehouse from, the U.S. financial sanctions.

“North Korea first filed its request to open an account with the Woori Bank on Sept. 14, 2005, one day before” Washington imposed sanctions on a Macau bank suspected of aiding the North launder counterfeit U.S. dollars, ministry spokesman Yang Chang-seok told reporters.

A spokesman for the South Korean bank said the bank first heard of the North’s request in December, but did not rule out the possibility that North Korea may have filed its initial request with the South Korean government as early as September.

Goh Gyeong-bin, the ministry official in charge of the inter-Korean project to develop an industrial complex in Kaesong, said an account with the South Korean bank, if one was opened, would not have provided a safe haven for the communist state.

“The North said it wished to open an account at the Woori Bank branch in Kaesong and collect the wages of its workers at the industrial complex through the account,” Goh said.

He said the South Korean bank remained reluctant to comply with the North’s request since the beginning and notified the North Korean side in March that it decided not to approve the request. Woori Bank officials confirmed Goh’s statement.

“The North said it understood the bank’s position and that’s when the situation was concluded,” Goh said.

Nearly 8,300 North Korean laborers are currently working for 13 South Korean firms operating in the joint industrial complex, producing some US$5 million worth of goods a month, according to Goh.

A number of U.S. officials, including Jay Lefkowitz, a special envoy for North Korean human rights, have expressed concerns over possible violations of the North Korean workers’ human rights there and the diversion of their wages to help the North’s weapons program.

Seoul dismisses the concerns, saying the amount of money paid in wages is insignificant even for the impoverished North.

About $600,000, in U.S. dollars, are paid each month to North Korean workers there, whose minimum monthly wage is set at $57, according to Goh.

The joint industrial complex is expected to house some 2,000 South Korean firms, employing as many as half a million North Koreans, when it is in full swing in 2012, according to the Unification Ministry.

From the Korea Herald
9/20/2006

A bank spokesman said Woori serves South Korean companies and their employees from the South producing goods there.

“We rejected the request because we are not regulated to handle transactions with North Korea,” said Cho Seong-kwon.

The request was made last December, Cho said. It came after the U.S. strengthened its crackdown on firms it suspected of aiding Pyongyang in illicit activities such as counterfeiting.

Washington imposed sanctions on a Macau bank in September, accusing it of helping North Korea launder counterfeit U.S. dollars.

A month later, the United States also froze U.S.-based assets of eight North Korean firms on suspicions of illegal activities, including counterfeiting, laundering and proliferation of weapons of mass destruction.

The Unification Ministry, however, said the North’s request had nothing to do with the U.S. sanctions, saying an account with Woori Bank, if one were opened, would not have been used for such illegal financial activities.

“The North said it wished to open an account at the Woori Bank branch in Gaeseong and collect the wages of its workers at the industrial complex through the account,” Goh Gyeong-bin, ministry official in charge of the joint industrial complex project, said.

Goh said the South Korean bank was reluctant to comply with the North’s request since the beginning and notified the North Korean side in March that it decided not to approve the request.

The complex is run by an affiliate of the South’s Hyundai Group. The South sees the park as a model of economic integration that can serve as an example of the path for future unification of the peninsula.

From the Joong Ang Daily:
Ministry says North sought bank account with Woori
Ser Myo-ja, Shin Eun-jin
9/20/2006

North Korea attempted last year to open an account with a South Korean commercial bank at the Kaesong Industrial Complex, but the request was rejected, the Ministry of Unification said yesterday.

In response to a report by the Dong-A Ilbo newspaper, the ministry said a North Korean agency made a verbal inquiry to the Kaesong Industrial District Management Committee on Sept. 14, 2005 about opening an account with Woori Bank. In December, the agency submitted a written request.

Seoul held about four meetings to talk about the issue, the ministry said, but the matter was basically up to Woori Bank.

The North Koreans were quoted by the ministry as saying they wanted to collect income taxes from South Korean workers at the inter-Korean industrial complex.

The North also said it wanted the convenience of collecting salary payments for North Korean workers from their South Korean employers.

North Korean officials must visit the office of each South Korean factory in Kaesong every month for all financial transactions.

Woori Bank has continued to reject the North’s requests. Under Korean law, the bank said, the scope of its operations was limited to South Korean companies that operate factories in Kaesong and their South Korean employees.

The bank has not sought permission from the South Korean government to extend operations to North Koreans in order to meet Pyongyang’s request, the Unification Ministry said.

North Korea threatened Woori Bank that it would shut down the branch, but gave up in March, the ministry said.

Posted in Banking, Kaesong Industrial Complex (KIC), South Korea, USA | Comments Closed

UK investor presses U.S. to ease N.Korea sanctions

Tuesday, September 5th, 2006

From Reuters:
9/5/2006

The chairman of British investment advisory firm Koryo Asia, which has bought North Korea’s Daedong Credit Bank, said on Tuesday it was pressing the U.S. to ease sanctions against the isolated communist country.

Colin McAskill confirmed to Reuters a newspaper report that Koryo Asia had taken over Daedong Credit Bank. Koryo is also an adviser to the Chosun Fund, which invests in North Korean assets.

“We will take on the U.S. over the sanctions stand-off. They’ve had it too much their own way without anyone questioning what they are putting out,” McAskill said in a report in the Financial Times on Tuesday.

Asked later by Reuters about the reported remarks, McAskill said, “That is true,” but declined to comment further.

North Korea defied international warnings and test-fired seven missiles in early July. Dubbed part of an “axis of evil” by U.S. President George W. Bush, the heavily militarised state enforces tight censorship and a strong personality cult of its leader Kim Jong-il.

The United States imposed strict economic sanctions on North Korea in 1950, some of which were eased under the Clinton administration in the 1990s.

The United Nations passed a resolution in July this year imposing sanctions on the country, demanding that North Korea suspend ballistic missile tests.

Daedong Credit Bank has most of its cash frozen under U.S. trade sanctions imposed last September, the Financial Times said. However, its new UK-based owners want to demonstrate that the accounts were earned legitimately and get sanctions lifted.

McAskill has asked U.S. officials to scrutinse the records of Daedong and has written to the U.S. Treasury department about the matter, the newspaper said.

The latest move comes after Anglo-Sino Capital, a firm based in London which is involved in day-to-day management of the Chosun Fund, won regulatory approval from Britain’s Financial Services Authority in May this year.

The Chosun Fund aims initially to raise $50 million, eventually rising to a total asset size of around $100 million, targeting, for example, a possible revival in North Korea’s financial and mining sectors.

Posted in Banking, Daedong Credit Bank, Economic reform, Finance, Foreign direct investment, Koryo Asia Ltd., USA | Comments Closed

Suspects Admits Smuggling N.Korean ‘Supernotes’

Monday, August 28th, 2006

From the Choson Ilbo
8/28/2006

A Californian man indicted on charges of smuggling counterfeit dollars into the U.S. testified at his trial that the high-quality counterfeit US$100 bills or “supernotes” were manufactured in North Korea, the National Intelligence Service said Monday. The NIS reported to the National Assembly’s Intelligence Committee that the man admitted conspiracy to smuggle the supernotes and admitted where the phony bills were made.

The man is a Chinese-American named Chao Tung Wu, the NIS said. There have been reports in the U.S. media quoting anonymous government officials as saying the supernotes were made in North Korea, but this is the first time the claim was confirmed in legal testimony by a chief suspect.

A joint taskforce of the FBI, the CIA, the Justice Department and the Treasury conducted secret investigations and rounded up 59 suspects around the U.S. on charges of smuggling counterfeit dollars and cigarettes in August last year. The taskforce worked under the code name “Smoking Dragon” and “Royal Charm” between 1999 and 2005. It alleges suspects attempted to smuggle millions worth of forged dollars and some $40 million worth of counterfeit cigarettes.

The case drew much publicity not only because of its sheer scale but also because of North Korea’s suspected involvement. The Treasury Department led the investigation that ended up designating Macao’s Banco Delta Asia as Pyongyang‘s “primary money laundering concern” on Sept. 15 last year, a month after the suspects were arrested.

“We should note that talk of political solutions between the U.S. and North Korea over the counterfeit dollars disappeared in South Korea and China since the end of last year,” a diplomatic source in Seoul said. Some until then claimed the U.S. was pressuring the North without clear evidence, but they lost their ground as Washington acquired evidence to support North Korea’s involvement.

The trial is likely to take one or two years, a diplomatic source said. If it ends with a guilty verdict for the main suspect for smuggling made-in-North Korea supernotes, it would get Pyongyang into serious trouble on the global stage. The North denies the charges and says the resulting sanctions amount to “theft.” The communist country in a statement last Saturday said the U.S. has produced no clear evidence so far. But the suspect’s guilty plea undermines the credibility of that claim.

Posted in Counterfeiting, Tobacco, USA | Comments Closed

North Korean cigarettes-big news day

Thursday, August 17th, 2006

Well the notion that the DPRK has been counterfitting cigarettes to raise hard currency has had a big day in the press. I saw stories alone.

From Yonahp:

Fake cigarettes are major source of income for N. Korea: report

North Korea is believed to earn between US$500 million and $700 million a year by making and selling fake U.S. and Japanese cigarettes, a U.S. radio station reported Wednesday, quoting a former U.S. official.

“Counterfeit tobaccos are one of the largest, probably the largest single source of income for the North Korean regime,” David Asher said in an interview with the Washington-based Radio Free Asia.

Asher, who until July 2005 had served under former Assistant Secretary of State for East Asia and Pacific Affairs James Kelly, said the North’s communist regime operates as many as 10 plants to make fake U.S. and Japanese cigarettes.

Those plants are scattered throughout North Korea, including its capital, Pyongyang, and its eastern industrial zone, Rajin, he said.

The counterfeit cigarettes, Asher said, are usually packed and sent in containers to China and then to other Asian countries for sale.

“They need to start inspecting containers more aggressively,” he told the radio station, referring to a recent decision by Japan to block the North’s massive scheme to make counterfeit cigarettes.

Tokyo has recently ordered investigation into North Korean-made fake Japanese cigarettes reportedly circulated in China, according to Japanese media reports.

The amount of North Korean-made fake U.S. and Japanese cigarettes is estimated at about 2 billion packs a year, they said.

Asher claimed in an earlier report that as much as 40 percent of North Korea’s total earnings is believed to come from illegal activities such as counterfeiting, drug trafficking and weapons smuggling.

From the Daily NK (for the Japanese perspective):

‘Fake Cigarettes’ Japan Investigation on North Korean Authorities
North Korea reels in an annual income of $80mn~$160mn through counterfeit cigarettes
By Yang Jung A, Reporter

At the Prime Minister’s residence last August 14th, Japan’s Deputy Chief Cabinet Secretary Suzuki Seiji who heads the ‘Special Investigation Team on Japanese abductees to North Korea’ initiated an official investigation on North Korean Authorities to combat the issue of counterfeit cigarettes.

A Japanese Newspaper ‘Mainichi’ (Daily News) reported that North Korea had been shipping large scale counterfeits of Japan’s leading cigarette brand ‘Mild Seven’ throughout China and South-East Asia in order to produce greater foreign currency.

The investigation by the ‘Special Investigation Team’ will focus on cracking whether or not North Korean authorities partook in the trafficking. On release of results, explicit countermeasures will be taken by the police, financial affairs, agriculture and fisheries and other ministries.

Last July 31st, Vice Minister Suzuki said at a ‘Special Investigation Team’ meeting that “There is a high possibility that North Korea is distributing ‘counterfeit cigarettes’ to foreign countries” and that severe measures will be taken.

The Japanese government argues that the flow of illegal foreign currency made through sales from fake cigarettes needs to be stopped if not at least for the persecution occurring in North Korea, and for the past few months has been pressurizing governments to take action.

A Japanese tobacco industry announced that masses of fake Mild Seven cigarettes were known to be circulating throughout China, North Korea and districts around the boarder. However, there is not yet confirmation that fake cigarettes are circulating in Japan.

Last May, the Japanese Maritime Bureau confirmed that a foreign vessel was found to be transporting fake Japanese cigarettes made in North Korea to South Korea and Taiwan. According to an U.S. press report the amount of fake cigarettes manufactured in North Korea and smuggled out of the country reaches $80-160 mn every year.

Posted in Counterfeiting, Japan, Tobacco, USA | Comments Closed

Isolated North Korea pulling back even more

Tuesday, August 1st, 2006

Joong Ang Daily
August 01, 2006

With North Korea more isolated than ever from the international community over its nuclear program and recent missile launches, Pyongyang is taking steps to tighten controls on its people in a bid to show it can defy the international community, North Koreans interviewed in Beijing said.

“It seems that we have to sing the revolutionary songs again,” said one North Korean in Beijing, saying it was time for his country to get mentally tougher. “Nobody listens to us, thus the only way left is to stick together,” the North Korean said.

If Pyongyang hoped to gain more concessions in nuclear negotiations and resolve the issue of financial sanctions imposed by Washington on Banco Delta Asia through its missile launch, the results have been the opposite.

A United Nations Security Council resolution backed by Pyongyang’s long-time ally, Beijing, was adopted. The Bank of China also froze North Korean accounts at its Macao branch, a Korean lawmaker has said.

In addition, a senior official of the United States Treasury Department said recently, Singapore and Vietnam have made commitments to clamp down on illicit North Korean financial activities such as money laundering.

A source in Seoul who is familiar with North Korea’s circumstances said yesterday that Pyongyang has decided to halt exchanges with the outside until April of next year. The Arirang Festival scheduled for this month has already been cancelled.

Experts said a series of economic measures aimed at reviving the North’s ailing economy, which have been underway since 2001, will also likely be put on hold.

“Inside the North, there are even some calling for a halt of the Kaesong Industrial Complex and the Mount Kumgang tours,” said the source, who added that large numbers of North Korean college students are submitting requests to enlist in the military.

Recently, a senior North Korean official on a visit to Beijing said the North is fully prepared to engage in “a march of suffering.” Recent rhetoric coming out of Pyongyang reflects a war-like atmosphere in the country. The state-run Rodong Sinmun has warned that “invaders would be swept away by the fierce anger of the country.”

A government official in Seoul yesterday admitted that in the short run, diplomatic efforts to lure Pyongyang back to nuclear negotiations would be tough. “We are in a difficult situation, but what else can we do but try?” said the official.

Posted in Arduous March, China, International trade, Japan, Kaesong Industrial Complex (KIC), Mt. Kumgang Tourist Special Zone, Political economy, South Korea, USA | Comments Closed

U.S. hails Bank of China’s freeze

Friday, July 28th, 2006

Joong Ang Daily
July 28, 2006

North’s accounts were in Macau branch, Korean legislator says

The United States is encouraged by Beijing’s “affirmative steps” in freezing North Korean accounts at a Chinese bank, White House Spokesman Tony Snow said on Wednesday.

His remarks were the first official confirmation of a South Korean lawmaker’s earlier claim that the Bank of China had frozen North Korean assets. Beijing remained silent on the issue after Grand National Party lawmaker Park Jin revealed the news, citing an unidentified former White House official as his source, after a trip to Washington.

Mr. Park said yesterday that the frozen accounts he was referring to were only in the Bank of China’s Macau branch, but that he is looking into whether the Beijing branch will make a similar move.

Mr. Snow was asked if Washington had knowledge of China’s actions in regard to freezing accounts. He answered yes, and said the move was related to counterfeiting issues.

In a related development, Stuart Levey, the undersecretary for terrorism and financial intelligence of the U.S. Treasury department warned yesterday in an interview with Yonhap News Agency that North Korea could use funds legally gained through trade for military purposes. A diplomatic source in Washington said yesterday the remarks by Mr. Levey could mean Washington might pressure Seoul about the Kaesong Industrial Complex and the Mount Kumgang tours, through which Pyongyang receives cash from the South.

A government official in Seoul said yesterday that if Washington tries to alter the current course of inter-Korean projects it would meet “heavy resistance” from Seoul.

Unification Minister Lee Jong-seok has repeatedly said the inter-Korean projects would not be influenced by North Korea’s recent missile salvo.

In October last year, the U.S. Treasury department designated eight North Korean entities as being involved in the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction. Under U.S. law, all transactions between the designated entities and any person in the United States are prohibited while all assets of these entities are frozen in territories under U.S. jurisdiction.

Posted in China, Counterfeiting, USA | Comments Closed

ROK caves on Kaesong in FTA talks

Thursday, July 27th, 2006

From Joong Ang Daily:

A high-level Korean government official yesterday suggested that the Kaesong Industrial Complex issue be dealt with seperately from the free trade talks with the United States.

“It would be appropriate to discuss the matter on whether products manufactured from Kaesong Industrial Complex in North Korea should be recognized as South Korean in origin in a separate discussion from the free trade negotiation between South Korea and the United States,” said Chin Dong-soo, deputy finance and economy minister.

Mr. Chin said that even though Korea has persistently brought up the issue during the second round of talks, which took place earlier this month in Seoul, there has been no detailed discussion between the two parties.

“If we continue to push the matter while there is no response from the U.S. party, other issues that are being discussed at the free trade talks will likely be jeopardized,” Mr. Chin said.

Posted in International trade, Kaesong Industrial Complex (KIC), South Korea, USA | Comments Closed

US warns ROK on sensitive materials to Kaesong but not too worried

Wednesday, July 26th, 2006

From Korea Times:

Control on Sensitive Materials to NK Tightened

South Korea’s Ministry of Commerce, Industry and Energy has issued a warning to 80,000 local companies against any shipments of strategic materials to North Korea, officials said Wednesday.

In an e-mail message sent to trading companies, the ministry said international pressure was mounting to prevent Pyongyang from acquiring materials that can be used for the production of weapons of mass destruction. North Korea has been condemned by many countries as well as the U.N. Security Council for firing a series of missiles into the East Sea on July 5.

The ministry also said that with U.S. lawmakers poised to pass a law that penalizes foreign companies that ship dual-purpose materials to North Korea, Washington is expected to strengthen its international monitoring activities.

The message said it could lead to sanctions being imposed on all violators discovered by the U.S. surveillance.

In addition, the ministry said South Korean firms should be careful of shipping products to China and some Southeast Asian countries that could be resold to North Korea.

“If companies have any doubts about whether or not their shipping of products violated the strategic material export rules, they should not hesitate to ask the government,” an official said. He added that companies that ship products to the inter-Korean industrial complex in the North Korean city of Kaesong, just north of the demilitarized zone separating the two Koreas, should be particularly careful.

South Korea is a signatory to the Wassenaar Arrangement, a multilateral pact that restricts the export of commercial products that can be used to make weapons to certain countries. The United Nations has also stressed the need to monitor such trade.

Authorities here have said they will step up efforts to detect and penalize violations.

From Korea Times:

Inter-Korean Economic Projects Not Worrisome’

By Park Song-wu, Lee Jin-woo

Inter-Korean economic cooperation programs are not a worry to the United States as the money ending up in North Korea is not likely to be used for developing weapons of mass destruction (WMD), a ranking U.S. finance official said.

In an interview with the Voice of America on Tuesday, U.S. Undersecretary of Treasury for Terrorism and Financial Crimes Stuart Levey said what Washington worries about is the North attempting to abuse international financial institutions to secure funds for its development of WMD.

He said the Kaesong industrial park project and the Mt. Kumgang tourism program _ the two examples of cross-border cooperation _ are not the concerns the U.S. government has in mind to safeguard the international financial system.

In a related development, the Kaesong complex is expected to churn out products worth a record high of $6 million this month, despite security concerns on the Korean Peninsula caused by the North’s missile launches on July 5, an official at the Unification Ministry said.

Denying a negative outlook for South Korean factories in Kaesong, Ko Gyoung-bin, who is in charge of supporting the project, said “everything is going perfectly okay.”

“The total production amount is expected to reach $6 million for the first time since its opening in June 2004, almost 100 percent up from $3 million of last December,” he said during a press briefing in Seoul on Wednesday.

Ko said the export volume of Kaesong products has also been steadily increasing from $1.1 million in May to $1.6 million in June.

“I don’t agree with recent reports which tried to link North Korea’s missile threats with the Kaesong complex,” he said. “I met a few working-level North Korean officials involved in the project last week and they were determined to continue this project.”

As for concerns whether the North Korean government properly pays their workers the wages sent by South Korean firms, Ko said he is confidant that the money has not been diverted for other purposes.

“South Korea has paid some $500,000 to $600,000 for those 7,800 workers and their families each month,” he said. “I don’t think there’s enough room for North Korean authorities to use part of the relatively small amount of money for other purposes.”

He added the number of North Korean workers in the complex would reach 8,000 this month.

A North Korean worker there earns $64 in wages and allowances a month. Most of the money is paid on the 10th of the month. This month, it was paid as scheduled.

South Korea paid $6 million to rent the complex site for 50 years in 2004.

Earlier this month, the Korea Land Corp., a state-run land developer, which has been involved in the Kaesong project, decided to postpone the sales of some 516,000 pyong (1.7 million square meters) of land in the industrial complex to both South Korean and multi-national companies.

Unlike the present South Korean firms in Kaesong, which benefited from the inter-Korean cooperation fund with low interest rates and a three-year grace period to pay back borrowed money, companies which wish to newly join the project will be required to get loans from commercial banks after getting credit guarantee notes issued by the state-run Korea Credit Guarantee Fund (KODIT).

The industrial complex is expected to house about 2,000 South Korean companies employing nearly half a million North Koreans when it comes into full swing in 2012, according to the ministry.

Posted in Kaesong Industrial Complex (KIC), South Korea, USA | Comments Closed

Recent moves to isolate DPRK don’t include Kaesong Industrial Zone

Wednesday, July 26th, 2006

From Yonhap:

Seoul to expand inter-Korean economic project despite U.S. concerns: official

A ranking South Korean official on Wednesday said the government may expand a joint industrial complex in North Korea’s border town of Kaesong at an early date despite concerns that money paid to North Korean laborers there may be used to build missiles.

“The Kaesong industrial complex is a project that runs strictly on the mechanism of a market system,” Goh Gyeong-bin, head of the office for the inter-Korean economic project at the Unification Ministry, told reporters.

He said the government may begin the next phase of the Kaesong development project as early as August or September, which would include leasing out 1 million pyeong of land at the joint complex to South Korean companies. One pyeong equals 3.3 square meters.

The remarks are in line with Seoul’s earlier stance that it does not need to halt the inter-Korean project despite concerns, mainly from the United States, that wages paid to North Korean workers may be forfeited and diverted by Pyongyang to build missiles and weapons of mass destruction.

The apparent opposition from Washington, although still tacit, intensified after North Korea launched seven ballistic missiles, including a long-range Taepodong-2 believed capable of hitting the U.S. west coast, earlier in the month, while the U.N. Security Council unanimously approved a resolution prohibiting missile-related dealings with the North.

South Korea’s point man on North Korean affairs, Unification Minister Lee Jong-seok, however, has refused to halt or suspend the economic project with the communist state, claiming the U.N. resolution does not require his or any other country to cut normal, legal economic relations with the North.

“What the international community, including the U.S., is worried about is the North making or taking money through illegal means,” Lee told a National Assembly committee on Monday.

Currently, 13 South Korean companies are operating at the industrial complex, where about 7,800 North Korean laborers are getting paid US$57 a month on average, according to Goh.

The ministry official said there was no way of knowing for sure whether the North Korean government was taking any of the wages, but claimed it wasn’t happening.

“There is no possibility. The amount tells us that,” Goh told Yonhap News Agency in a later telephone interview.

“Even though North Korea is an extremely poor state, it would take at least 50,000 (South Korean) won (about $50) on average to feed a family of four for a month,” he claimed.

He said the South Korean companies are paying about $500,000 to $600,000 a month to 7,862 North Korean employees.

“The issue (of possible diversion of funds) may become significant when the amount grows to a significant level through second and third phases (of the development project), but it really is not an issue at this time,” he said in the press briefing.

Between 300 to 800 South Korean companies, depending on the size of each business, are expected to move into the joint complex when the next phase of the development plan is completed, according to Goh.

The industrial complex is expected to house about 2,000 South Korean companies employing nearly half a million North Koreans when it comes into full swing in 2012, according to the Unification Ministry.

Posted in Kaesong Industrial Complex (KIC), South Korea, USA | Comments Closed

ROK insists Kaesong Products made in ROK, US says “nope”

Monday, July 24th, 2006

UPDATE: Contrary to a previous post (Listed below), South Korea is now insisting that goods made in the Kaesong Industrial Zone be labeled “Made in South Korea” for trade with the US, and the US is insisting that this will not be possible under the proposed FTA. I hope someone will blink because reduced trade barriers will be good for both countries.

From the Joong Ang:

U.S. reaffirms its stance against Kaesong in FTA
7/25/2006

Franklin Lavin, the U.S. Department of Commerce international trade undersecretary, has reiterated the American position not to include goods produced in the Kaesong Industrial Complex in North Korea in the free trade agreement with South Korea.

“The simple fact is that a bilateral agreement is between two countries,” Mr. Lavin said in a lecture organized by the American Chamber of Commerce yesterday.

“We have no negotiating authority, no congressional authority, to include any other economic entity in that bilateral agreement.”

Koreans negotiators, pushing to include Kaesong products in the FTA with the U.S., cited earlier free trade pacts with Chile and Singapore, which accepted the offer, as a precedent.

From the KBS:

Seoul Not to Compromise Kaesong Label
Friday, July 21, 2006

A top aide to South Korean President Roh Moo-hyun said Friday the South Korean government will not compromise on the issue of labeling goods manufactured in the inter-Korean industrial complex Kaesong as ‘South Korean-made’ in the ongoing talks for a free trade agreement (FTA) with the United States.

Senior presidential secretary for economic affairs Chung Moon-soo said that Seoul will never yield to Washington regarding the country-of-origin issue for South Korean products made in the Kaesong Industrial Complex.

South Korea’s Trade Minister Kim Hyun-chong also expressed a similar stance on the issue.

Earlier in Washington, U.S. Congress International Relations Committee Chairman Henry Hyde reportedly urged the U.S. government not to regard products made in Kaesong as South Korea-made.

In addition, Deputy U. S. Trade Representative Karan Bhatia has made clear that any deal that is beneficial to North Korea would run counter to the U.S. government’s position.

From the Korea Times:

Korea May Not Insist on Kaesong
By Park Hyong-ki
7/20/2006

Kim Jong-hoon, chief of Korea’s negotiating team with the United States on a free trade agreement (FTA), Thursday hinted that Seoul may not insist on including the Kaesong issue in the bilateral trade pact.

“We have not decided on which areas we will defend at all costs,’’ Kim told economic editors of newspapers and broadcasting stations. “I will consult decision-makers on the list.’’

Kim’s remarks came after last week’s negotiations in Seoul where the U.S. delegation, led by Wendy Cutler, rejected Seoul’s request for the exemption of tariffs on products made in the South Korean-led industrial complex in the North Korean town, in the event Kaesong-made goods are exported to the U.S.

The U.S. has reportedly been sensitive to transfers of cash to North Korea for fear they may sustain Pyongyang’s programs of weapons of mass destruction. About 6,000 North Korean workers work in Kaesong for about $60 per month. Kaesong is still in a developing stage so if more companies move in to set up shop, it would spell larger cash flows into the financially-strapped communist state.

Regarding Seoul’s decision to halve “screen quota’’ or its mandatory 146-day viewing of Korean films at theaters before FTA talks began, Kim said, “It provided an atmosphere conducive to the start of FTA negotiations.’’

He said that previous efforts to establish a bilateral trade pact with the United States were thwarted over the screen quota issue.

“We believed that if the screen quota remained intact, it would hobble any agreement at the last minute,’’ he said. “Besides, culture is a two-way street. We can’t just keep on insisting our position.’’

Talking about the rupture of the second round talks, Kim said that Wendy Cutler, chief U.S. negotiator, didn’t have authority to make spot decisions so had to consult with Washington, costing a lot on negotiating time.

The two sides are scheduled to meet for the third round in September in U.S.

Here is the position of the US (From the Donga)

The dissensions that had grown between Korea and the U.S. over the Gaesong Industrial Complex and tourism of Mt. Geumgang show signs of evolving into serious rifts.

At the U.S.-Korea Inter-Parliamentary Exchange Council press conference held at Rayburn House in Washington on July 18, the American chairman Edward Royce (Republican) emphasized the importance of where the profits from the industrial complex end up, stating the concern that the North Korean leadership may use the cash it earns for developing weapons of mass destruction such as missiles,

Officials from the Bush administration also recently noted that three laws on terrorism must be amended if the U.S. was to allow tax-free imports of goods produced in countries that support terrorism, such as North Korea, adding that such revision would be impossible for the U.S. Congress to accept. In effect, the U.S. will not be including products made in the Gaesong Industrial Complex in the Korea-U.S. Free Trade Agreement negotiations, because of the inconsistencies with existing laws and regulations.

Stuart Levey, U.S. Treasury`s undersecretary for terrorism and financial intelligence who visited Korea on July 16-18 is also reported to have met with Korean government officials and expressed a deep interest in whether a U.N. Security Council Resolution controlling the shipping of military supplies into North Korea would conflict with Mt. Geumgang tourism and the Gaesong complex.

In his statement upon departure from Seoul, disclosed on the U.S. Treasury website on July 18, he declared that they had discussed “issues of common interest, including the new United Nations Security Council Resolution that requires all member states to prevent the transfer of any financial resources in relation to DPRK`s missile or WMD programs.”

On July 18 Levey visited the Ministry of Finance and Economy (MOFE) and requested to know the Korean government’s position on the recent Security Council’s Resolution against North Korea; however a senior MOFE official replied that as the issue lies with the Ministry of Unification, MOFE was not in a place to provide an answer.

“We explained it [to Undersecretary Levey before he asked] because some concerns had been raised that the U.N. Security Council Resolution could clash with the Mt. Geumgang tourism and Gaesong Industrial Complex,” said Song Min-soon, chief presidential secretary for unification, foreign and security policy.

He went on to deny allegations that tensions had arisen between the two countries over the issue, stating that “Korean government officials had expressed there was no problem with the two enterprises regarding the purpose and range of domestic statutes, judicial judgement or international law mentioned in the Security Council Resolution, and Undersecretary Levey had responded that he understood well.”

While Washington has not demanded outright for South Korea to stop its industrial and tourism enterprises in the North, it has been reported to have conveyed strong concerns over the businesses bringing cash into North Korea.

However, a senior Korean official displayed a firm determination in pursuing the Gaesong project. “The Gaesong Industrial Complex is the epitome of the [current administration’s] North Korean policies. We will carry on with it no matter what difficulties are to be faced,” he said.

Fears have been raised that in case North Korea follows its arbitrary announcement on July 19 that it will no longer permit meetings of separated families with further measures to step up tension on the peninsula, South Korea and the U.S. could come to serious troubles over the Gaesong and Mt. Geumgang projects.

Meanwhile, a group of 56, comprised of people from credit assurance companies and from corporate banking divisions of banks such as Kookmin, Shinhan, Hana, Woori, Korea Development Bank (KDB), Kiup, City Bank Korea, Daegu, Busan, Kwangju, Jeonbuk and Kyongnam will be visiting the Gaesong Industrial Complex on July 21, sponsored by the Ministry of Unification.