North Korean Economy Watch

August 15, 2006 was the 60th anniversary of the end of world War II.  In North Korea this date is known as the “Victory over Japanese Imperialism,” when the Great Leader, President Kim il Sung, defeated the Japanese colonialists and liberated the Koreans from servitude–or something like that.   In honor of this auspicious date Pyongyang hosted the Arirang Mass Games. 

As an American, I could not travel as a tourist to see the games.  Therefore, to see them I had to be a member of a cultural delegation (visas issued by separate ministries).  So despite what had happened on my previous visit, I signed up to join the KFA on another delegation trip.  The irony is that starting in October 2005 the North Koreans began allowing American tourists to enter the country to see the Mass Games, and they have done so each year since.

Aside from my pictures, here are others from Naerna (1,2,3,4), Bjornar’s, and some others.  Mana Sapmak has good pictures taken on the KFA business delegation shortly after my trip.  Jason LaBouyer was interviewed at Berkeley.  Someone with Koryo tours also took these photos.  Also, the KFA wrote all about it in their defunct publication, Lodestar.

As in the previous year, I left Beijing on an Air Koryo flight to Pyongyang.  This year, I tried to get some pictures of the stewardesses (which is not easy). The only memorable event on this flight was the ENORMOUS French (or Belgian) man sitting across the aisle from me.  He was so fat that his meal tray could not be lowered over his voluminous stomach.  The poor stewardess did not know what to do when it came time to feeding him.  I am not sure if he even got to eat his generous Air Koryo meal.  When we landed in Pyongyang, I was one of the last to leave the plane.  While waiting for a bus to carry me to the terminal, I noticed an interesting way that Air Koryo staff supplement their incomes…

   

          

               

   

Since this was a celebration event, there were many DPRK solidarity groups, of which the KFA was just one, we stayedin the Yangdakdo Hotel (A big improvement over our stay in the Sosan Hotel the previous year).  At the Yangdakdo Hotel, there was a ceremony to present gifts to the Leader, and several members of the KFA did just that.  The senior members of the KFA also sang a song.  What was interesting to note was the attitude of the Koreans to this spectacle.  Many foreigners made long speeches when they presented their gifts, but several Koreans were literally complaining about all the hot air coming out of these foreigners’ mouths.  They were literally of the opinion “Come on, no need to talk so much.” All of these gifts will someday be on display in Mt. Myohyangsan International Friendship Exhibition, including David’s miniature Statue of Liberty!

   

  1.   2.

1. This picture was taken at the KFA meeting in Beijing, which I did not attend.
2. KFA members are into wearing as many badges as they can.  Photographed here is the coveted “Gold” KFA membership badge, reserved for the KFA leadership-Alejandro, Bjornar, Jason, and Mana.

Grand People’s Study House
The next morning, we awoke to discover that the “senior” KFA members had all left town to fly to Mt. Pektu for the commemoration of a new monument.  This left everyone else in the group to get to know each other out from under the watchful eye of the senior KFAers.  There were plenty of other KFAers there taking notes on us, however, and this was fine with me–all part of the experience.  (Once I got the details afterwards, the trip to Pektusan did not sound like much fun).  The first tourist stop for those of us “left behind” was the Grand Peoples’ Study House.  It was fun to visit again and see the place for the second time.  We walked into an English class being taught by a Canadian.  She was paid in Euros and lived in the central district.  She was recruited from China apparently.  Check out the notes from one of her students below.

               

   

            

   

   

Kim Il Sung Square
Since it was summer time, the “good” school children were out in the square practicing for a march in October.  They were already pretty far along.  In the few minutes I watched them, they accomplished several complex transitions.  One of my guides, Mr. Han, said “you can do this with a very organized society, and Korea is very organized.”  No doubt.  These kinds of activities keep children occupied in groups throughout their summer break.  Idle hands, after all…

1  2.

1. “100 battles, 100 victories”
2. “1000 times-don’t waste good abilities–protect and use them”

1   

1. Long Live the Dongjie (Comrade Kim Jong Il)

   

 

National History Museum
Afterwards, we visited the Natural History Museum on the square.  Nothing too memorable about it except they had a mock up of the world’s first iron clad ship.  Also, I got a chance to practice with the children briefly out on the square.

   

         

Moranbong Middle School
This trip to Moranbong was not as memorable as last year’s visit.  School had already let out for the day, so the place was half empty.  The children did put on a small show for us.  I think I even recognized a few (I still have not compared the pictures).  I tried to convince the girl playing the guitar to let me borrow it so I could play some songs, but she would not let go of it.  I was a little disappointed.  I doubt these kids have heard any “Nirvana,” and I was itching to jam with them.  One other interesting note, Pyongyang’s neighborhoods still burn all their own refuse.  I guess this is why I never saw a garbage man or a landfill.  We did see a burning facility outside the school next to a playground.

   1      2  

1. “Celebrate”
2. “Lets everybody support the slogans and be good students in school” “Let’s learn from Kim Il Sung when he was young”

12

1. Ten rules students should have to know: 1.  Revere Kim Il Sung and Kin jong Il 2. think about the group as the most important 3. You have to love your “Dongmu” 4.You must be very respectful 5.We have to use respectful language to each other 6.You have to be respectful in public 7.Remember the traffic rules 8.When you are in school you have to obey the rules 9. You have to always be clean and keep your area clean 10. You have to act like the new generation of Juche Korea

2. The Juche Idea is shining through the whole world.  The 21st century is the Kim Jong Il century.

    1.   
1. The world of physics

  1.

1. Lets be like young soldiers loyal to Kim Jong Il

1.   

1. Lets finish our drama quickly

                 

   

Pyongyang Circus
The Pyongyang circus was on my 2005 wish list, so I was happy to see it.  I sat close to Mr. Han, who explained some of the humor to me.  It was interesting to hear him describe a skit about a ration coupon without actually knowing how to convey the idea of it in English.  The acrobats were fine, but required safety strings–something that would never fly at Ringling Brothers.

      1         

1. The everything circus

        

   

 

Pyongyang Maternity Hospital
The maternity hospital was also on my wish list for the trip.  To be honest, I thought it was a show piece.  The doctors would all put on their hats and look busy when we entered the room.  The patients all had makeup and did not think it was strange that a whole flock of westerners were walking in to examine them, unlike the rest of the entire population.  Additionally, the rooms all had western (sitting) toilets, which the guides told me Koreans did not use.  Also, a lot of the equipment they showed us was not being used.  So I was skeptical about it all.  Then I spoke to a friend that I trust and was assured that it was a functioning hospital because this person had been treated there.  So I guess it serves several purposes after all. 

   

             

    

*   

*”I want that you work hard for the people” Kim Jong Il

    

Book Shop

 * 
*A picture of me visiting Sinchon in 2004-posted on the wall in a Pyongyang book shop

Children’s Palace
As in the previous year, I visited the Children’s palace near Manyongdae.  This visit was better because I saw a whole range of activities I did not see the year before (when the place was a mad house and we had just gotten back from Nampo).  We saw children playing piano, drawing, practicing tae kwon do, and dancing in different styles.  The visit was capped off with a performance as was done the year before.  It seemed exactly the same, except maybe less obvious propaganda.

     

   

               

   

   

   

Manyongdae Children’s Fun Fair (part 2)
I had visited the fun fair the previous year, but to my surprise I discovered the park is much larger than I thought and it has two entrances.  This time around, I visited a completely different part of the park.  Whereas the roller coaster was the big show last year, this time it was the log flume.  I always thought of log flumes as particular to logging in the US, but maybe they use/d them here as well.  Anyway, no one was at the park this year, so the whole place had a bit of a ghost-town feel to it. 

    

   

     

 

Tower of the Juche Idea
We visited the tower of the Juche Idea again.  This repeat was also worth it because like in Kim Il Sung Square, people were training for the October parade.  It was interesting to see them drilling.  I got my picture taken with the huge portraits of the leaders (below).  About four or five of us got pictures like this, and then one of the men in charge of the training came and chased the group away.  Looking down at the people from the top was very interesting.  Also, I climbed up on the wall of the tower for a better picture of the torch.  Mr. Han got very scared when I leaned back over the edge.  I told him I used to rock climb all the time and I am not scared of heights.  He replied, “but if you fall, I will be in big trouble.”

   

 1 

1. Lets be like brave soldiers for Kim Jong Il

    

   

Party Foundng  Museum
The monument to the party founding was also on my wish list.  If I remember correctly, the guide at the monument told us that Kim Jong Il asked the workers to finish this monument in a single day…and they did.  WOW…You can’t really tell from the pictures, but this thing is BIG.  It is also lined up directly with the statue of Kim Il Sung on Mansu hill on the opposite side of the river. 

*    

*Long live the Korean Workers Party!  It will lead us to Victory!  100 wars 100 victories!

          

1. 2.3.

1. lets follow our leader even 1000 [miles?]
2. Spirit of Paektu
3. Lets use our hands.  we are self sufficient.

   

Nampo
We also made a trip to Nampo to see the West Sea Barge.  Here is a little advice to future DPRK travelers:  The trip to the barge is not worth the time.  You drive for a significant amount of time to Nampo (a restaurant along the way was serving US rice food aid to tourists–sorry, I lost the picture a fellow traveler took)-you get out of the bus on top of a hill, look down at the barge, watch a hysterical video with Jimmy Carter visiting the construction of the barge, then get back in your car for the return trip.  You are much better off staying in your hotel drinking all manners of North Korean alcoholic beverages and asking your guide which he prefers and why.  Another person who was traveling in the DPRK at the same time as me also sent me photos of private street vendors selling fruit (below).  He saw them when his bus got lost. 

   

   

 

Mansudae Hill
I visited Mansu Hill again and forgot to take a picture of the Great Leader and I (again).  I did walk down the hill and up the street to the Cholima Horse, then took a back trail to the top of the hill.  I met an old woman and a little girl who were cleaning the path.  All I could do was smile and say “hello.”

   

         

                

Supreme People’s Assembly

   

Chollima Horse

12 

                         3

1. All the military and people are united.  Lets show our power.
2. 60th anniversary of our country’s independence from the Japanese
3. 60th Anniversary of the party founding.  Lets do what the slogans tell us and put everyting into it.

Reunification Meeting
Thankfully we did not have to attend much of this.  There were too many speeches from representatives of such upstanding nations as Belarus and Cuba.  The (American) man who represented the US at this meeting seemed to have no other platform other than that he hated Jews and Israel.  I sat in my chair and studied for my comprehensive economics exams (which I had to take for my masters degree the day after I returned home).  It was fun because one of our guides was an economist who had studied in Singapore.  He was looking at copies of old exams I had and trying to answer the questions himself.  While everyone else was talking about imperialism, we were talking about marginal utility and constraint maximization functions. 

The meeting was covered in the pro-DPRK press.

   

   

 

Spy Ship Pueblo 
The visit to the Pueblo the second time was not memorable.  It was full of tourists.  The thing that was most memorable was the fact that there was a huge Dodge Van parked out front.  It was so huge and out of place, everyone was looking at it and gawking.  The “Spy Ship Dodge Van”…

   

Tomb of Tongmyong
This place did not do much for me largely because it was recently reconstructed (looked brand new) and it was empty.  One thing that I did notice were the beautiful trees around it.  I had realized at that point I had been in the city so long that I was surprised to be surrounded by trees again.

 

   

Pongsu and Catholic Church
Several members of the group asked our guides if they could go to the Catholic Church on Sunday morning.  The group was scheduled to visit another remodeled tomb and then on to the closing ceremony of the reunification meeting listed above.  When I heard that some people were going to church instead, I asked to join them.  How often do you get to go to church in Pyongyang?  When Sunday morning rolled around, me and the small group of Catholics climbed into a small bus.  When we arrived at the church, I recognized it immediately as the Pongsu Protestant Church.  The pastor came outside and met us.  We all chatted for a bit.  Finally, one of the catholic members of the group insisted that we needed to go to the Catholic Church, not the Protestant Church.  The Koreans were embarrassed by this slip so they gave everyone the option to stay at Pongsu or go to the Catholic church.  Since I had seen this one, I decided to go to the Catholic Church.  Why see one when you can see two?  So then they took us across town to the Catholic church.  We missed most of the mass, and they did not offer communion because they do not have an ordained priest on staff.  They only perform communion when a priest visits from the south.  All other times a deacon of sorts officiates the service.  The crowd was mostly women and they were not wearing their Kim Il Sung badges.  They put them on immediately after the service was over.  Even though the church is state-owned, they took a collection.  I helped an older lady collect the prayer books when the service was over.

   

   

   

March for Reunification
As in the previous year, there was another “March for Reunification” (“Tongil” in Korean).  Unlike last year, there was actually a large number of foreigners present.  The bizarre group from the year before must have looked silly to the Koreans, but this year there were several hundred imperialists among them.  All of the disparate groups from around the world supported by the Committee for Cultural Relations with Foreign Countries came to participate this time.  Two things happened here that I will always remember.  The first is that I hate political speeches, no matter who is giving them.  The foreigners here were all giving dreadfully long speeches and were literally saying the exact same things.  I could not handle it, so I was chatting with some Korean friends who had no interest in listening either.  One Japanese man passed out in the heat, and Dr. David “Studly” Borenstein jumped to the rescue.  He began to treat the man for heat exhaustion and encouraged him to drink fluids.  Eventually a Korean doctor showed up and injected the man with some kind of “upper” she had.  I asked another guide what the injection was and she did not know the English name for it.  She mentioned that she had also been given a shot of this in the past when she fainted at a political rally.  This makes me wonder how often Koreans keel over at political rallies. This diversion was welcome–I was lucky enough to miss a whole speech while fanning the man to cool him off.  Also, we saw an elite North Korean girl use a cell phone.  The day before our guides told us cell phones had been collected for security reasons.  They just smiled and shrugged when I pointed it out.  They said “she must be special.  We are too ordinary.”  

David “Studly” Borenstein was also interviewed by Anna Fifield from the Financial Times, who was covering the week’s events.  He asked her out.  She said “no.” Surprised?

     

     

     

   

         

   

Kamsusan Palace
Kamsusan is a very sacred place to North Koreans.  When I came here the previous year, I was touched by all the North Koreans crying.  This year, the place seemed more festive.  There were so many families and groups out in the courtyard spending time with each other and enjoying themselves.  It was really great to just hang out with them and take pictures.

          

   

   

Changwang Street
This street is known as “Restaurant Street.”  It is home to the Koryo Hotel and what expats call the “Forbidden City”–executive apartments for family of the Korean Worker’s Party Central Committee.  I was hoping to get some time to see and eat at one of these restaurants.  Unfortunately all of our meals were in the hotel and I did not get to try any of them.  These restaurants charge North Korean won, but take market prices into account.  Although the official rate in the hotel is 100KW per $1US, the market exchange rate is closer to 3,000KW per $1US (which is the rate at the Tongil Market).  At the price of 3000 KW for dumplings (price at one restaurant), that is a $30 plate of dumplings at the official hotel rate. A more reasonable $1 at market prices.

   

   

Banquet
We had a banquet with Kim Yong Nam.  I did not take a picture with him, but Alejandro did.  Kim Yong Nam is the official head of state, and he had some very nice things to say about the KFA.  The Soju was smooth also.  I took the bottle back to my room and was yelled at by some other foreigner for being greedy as I walked out of the restaurant.  Mr. Kim, my guide, had to assure her it was ok.  Tim Beal managed to get an attendance list.

   

Art Studio
We went back to the Mansudae art studio.  The previous year, they had an awesome brass-looking statue of a gorilla wearing boxing gloves.  My picture of it did not come out.  Unfortunately, it was not there this year.  Ces la vie!

*    

*Lets revere our son of Paektu mountain

 1 2

1. Lets revere comrade Kim Jong Il.  He is the brain of our revolution.
2. 56 days until the 60th anniversary of independence.  Are you doing your work for it?

Gala in Kim Il Sung Square
Because of rain, this Gala (and the Mass Games) were delayed one day.  As a result, this gala was held on August 15 (Liberation Day) and the Mass Games were held on the 16th.  This delay messed up many people’s schedule because they had made plane reservations for the morning of the 16th to return to Beijing.  So this gala was the only form of celebration they saw.  I had a great time.  It was thrilling.  I will never forget walking out to the crowd, turning around and seeing the enormous Grand People’s Study House illuminated in the dark.  It was truly incredible.  And so many North Koreans to dance with…how could you not have a good time!

*  

*60th celebration of independence

   

   

         

   

   

   

   

   

   

     

 

   

Sinchon and “Indignation Meeting”
The evening before “The International Indignation Meeting Against the US Crimes in Korea,” I was up until the middle of the night first drinking with the Koryo Tours group who happened to be staying in the same hotel, then drinking with three of my Korean guides in their room.  Great conversations all around and an experience I will never forget.  But the next morning, I seemed to be the only one that was hung over.  Since the Sinchon museum was a repeat visit for me, I also knew what the drive would be like.  So I remembered to bring a pillow along so I could sleep on the bus.  When we arrived at the museum, I just sat outside not feeling well with our guides and some other KFA members that were preparing to give speeches.  They were each given their speeches to read, and since the English translations were quickly done by the Koreans, they suffered from severe “Konglish” problems.  So one KFA member tried to plead with the Koreans that he could not read his speech as it was written because everyone would start laughing.  The Korean in charge of the speeches did not understand this.  It took a lot of convincing to get the Koreans to agree to let him rewrite the speech because they did not understand why it was funny and they were worried that they would not have time to accurately translate it to Korean. 

The meeting was brutal.  All the foreigners talked and talked.  It never seemed to end.  All of the Koreans who could crouched in the back under the trees (including the girl with the cell phone), other less-fortunate citizens stood erect in the sun for over an hour.  It was enough to make me livid.  All those people forced to stand in the sun to listen to foreigners droll on and on.  After the event, I complained to my guide that stuff like this could be done indoors, or at least with people sitting, but this kind of input did not strike him as particularly important.  One KFA member tried to tell me that everyone who was hot was jointly “sacrificing” for the revolution, including himself.  I thought this was silly as I define sacrifice as the assumption of risk for a higher probability of a direct reward.  This was useless sacrifice, and the only time I ever lost my temper in Korea.

They claim to have sent a letter to the UN Commission for Human Rights.

     

          

   

Mass Games (Arirang)
Since Kim Jong Il was there, no cameras were allowed.  The below picture is from Naenara, covering Kim Jong Il’s attendance.  I was sitting not to far to the left of this picture.  The Mass Games were performed by 100,000 citizens, and the performance was something you have to see to believe.  In the future, I will post some pictures others took on nights when cameras were allowed. The games were also covered by the Choson Ilbo.

  

Trip to Wonsan
The trip to Wonsan was particularly sad this year because our guide, Mr. Han, who was about my age and let me call him “dongmu” drowned while swimming.  Mr. Han was an only child of a DPRK diplomat with the Foreign Ministry.  He had lived in Europe for a long time, spoke British English, and had hoped to study at Cambridge.  He went out into the water and never came back.  We all ran up and down the beach looking for him, to no avail.  There were several folks on the beach with binoculars, but they were not supposed to be watching the water.  They were supposed to watch us.  We were later told that Mr. Han’s body washed ashore in the middle of the night and that his family had been notified.  There were several little inconsistencies in the story as it was explained to me, which led me to believe that his body had not been recovered.  But I understood that the Koreans as good hosts were trying to ease our minds and assure us that everything had been resolved.  As a note to future tourists, there are several things to note about the beaches in Wonsan: 1.  There are no phone lines.  If you are in trouble, you are on your own.  2.  There might be some netting in the water in which you could get tangled.  One member of the group claimed to have gotten his foot caught in some netting under water.  I have no idea if this is true or not.  3.  The last is that “under toes” or “rip tides” can be strong even when the water does not look fierce.  If you are being pulled away from shore, swim parallel to the beach, not towards it.  If you swim parallel, you will get out of the rip faster and can then swim back to shore.

Even though the day was particularly sad, I did have a great experience in Wonsan before we noticed Mr. Han was missing.  I walked out on the pier with a bunch of DPRK teenagers, and one of them asked me where I was from, in English.  I told her “America.”  After she told all the others they all showed instant interest in me and surrounded me on the pier.  This was the only time that I had ever had access to North Koreans who could speak English without a guide present.  I asked them a few questions and told them about myself.  Particularly that there were lots of Korean restaurants in the Washington area I enjoyed and that my judo instructor was from Seoul.  They wanted to take a picture with me, but could not find a camera on the beach.  While they were looking for a camera, a security agent came and yelled at them for talking to me.  Then he turned and yelled at me.  I knew exactly what he wanted me to do (return to the foreigner’s side of the beach), but I stood there and played stupid to let the Korean kids see it was their security people who were keeping us apart.  Afterwards, I grabbed them, brought them to the foreigners side of the beach, took their picture with my camera, and got their mailing addresses.  I sent them the pictures, but have no idea if they ever got them.

   

   

 1

1. The Great Leader Kim Il sung will always be with us

  *

*notice the Nike swoosh?

 1 

1. Lets do what our party is saying

   

 

Hanging out at the Taedonggang Diplomatic Club
I have spent more time than I could imagine at this diplomatic club.  You can get alcohol, play pool, Chinese checkers, and karaoke.  I met an interesting employee of the UN World Food Program he told me 6 million North Koreans depended on food aid.  Also, he told me that cigarettes are rationed for ordinary North Koreans.  You can’t just go buy them, apparently.  We all sang and flirted with the girl behind the bar.  She was surprised to hear I owned a car.

   

Yangdakdo Hotel Pics
The Yangdakdo is on an island in the Taedong river on the south side of town.  It is nothing special, but it is way better than the Sosan.  It has BBC news, Chinese television, and a Japanese channel.  The tailor who made some North Korean clothes for me, however, can only pick up the main state channel in her office.  She is so sweet.  The hotel has a bowling alley, pool, health clup, bordello, and CASINO!  It is run by a Macao-based firm and lots of Chinese were down there.  No pictures are allowed. 

   

123

1. If our Great Leader is here, we will always win
2. Everybody in the party, military, and all people have to be like one to keep our revolution -kil Jong Il
3. Lets make our things of higher quality to sell to the foreigners -Kim Jong Il

   

 *      *     

*These two images are of me visiting in 2004 on display in the hotel lobby!  This same picture was also posted in a book store!  Never have I seen such celebrity!  The guides thought this was funny.  

   

   

Random Pyongyang photos:

1 

1. Lets do what the slogan says keep the military strong and unify the party to receive the anniversary

1234

1. Our revolutionary brain that unites the military and the people.  Follow the Ranam torch.  Lets do what the party says.
2. The road is the face of the country, so lets keep it clean and make it better.
3. Everybody-lets do our work for the anniversary.
4. don’t worry about if there are roads.  we will take care of it.  

1 

1. Lets do what the public slogans say.  It is the revolutionary spirit and idea.

123 

1. The Great Leader Kim Il Sung will live in our hearts forever
2. The “Whistle”-locally produced Fiat
3. Spirit of All Military revolution

1.   2

1. Lets fight for our revolutionary brain
2. The 21st century is the Kim Jong Il Century

   

1.   

1. In our generation, lets make the country united

   

   

   

   

1.   2.

1. Whether we live or die, we will support the revolution

2. Long live Kim Jong Il (Used to be Kim il sung).  Long live the glorious party.

 1. 

1. Long live the plan for reunification.  It will not fail.

   1.

1. the Great Leader Kim Il Sung will live in our hearts forever 

After gaining my first exposure to the DPRK in 1996 from a Lonely Planet book on North East Asia, I was immediately curious about the country.  Off-and-on for several years I informally studied the DPRK.  In July 2004 I had the opportunity to visit the DPRK for the first time, which I did not think was possible until my plane landed in Pyongyang.  I was thrilled to be one of only a handful of Americans allowed into the country that year.

I travelled with the Korean Friendship Association, which might raise some eyebrows among readers.  The Korean Friendship Association is a pro-Pyongyang organization sponsored by the DPRK’s Committee for Cultural Relations with Foreign Countries (historically it is also known as the “Society for Cultural Relations…”).  Most communist naitons had similar offices with similar names.  DPRK offices with the word “Committee” in them seem to be the socialist alternative of “civil society” in more pluralistic countries.  The CCRFC’s mission seems to be to build these civil-society level contacts and constituencies in other countries to facilitate exchanges between the DPRK and these groups, bypassing the formal state- and ministerial-level channels of exchange.  I am only guessing about this, however…A brief introduction to the KFA can be found in a Naerna interview with Pak Kwang-ung, the secretary of the Korea-Spain Friendship Society and the KFA’s sponsor in the DPRK.

The CCRFC engages many overseas groups, such as the KFA and the National Lawyers Guild, in various cultural and informational exchanges.  In return, these groups bolster the Committee’s portfolio and budget by participating in DPRK friendship activities and exchanges.  The CCRFC and KFA have recently undertaken more explicit efforts at attracting foreign direct investment.

So why go with the KFA and not a regular tour group?  Firstly, Americans were not offered tourist visas at the time (except for the rare Mass Games festival).  Ironically, the Mass Games have been held annually since 2005 and more Americans than ever before are making the trip.  Secondly, I wanted to learn as much as possible about the DPRK from their unique perspective.  Joining the KFA delegation seemed to offer a solution to both of these concerns.  The experience was composed of activities I never expected nor things I will ever forget.

This web page is designed for me to warehouse as much information as possible about my trip to the DPRK in 2004.  Below, I have put all my pictures and comments.  Plus I have added the content that others from the trip have put on the web:

1. The trip was filmed and turned into a documentary called Friends of Kim.  It is on Youtube here: Part 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8.

2. Peter wrote an article for his college paper and posted this video on line in 2008 (description here). Peter also posted these clips on YouTube: here (at the DMZ) and this one documenting how Andrew was treated.

3. In 2003 Alejandro Cao de Benos was interviewed by KCNA.  Here is the KFA description in Wikipedia.

4. Here is the KFA photo gallery and Nayan’s photo set: 1, 2, and 3.

5. Here are pictures of the trip I found on Naenara: 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8.

Photos from 2004 trip to DPRK

We began in Beijing’s Capital Airport.  Air Koryo flights are designated with the call letters JS.  Air Koryo flights from Beijing are on an Ilyushin Il-62.  When I stepped on the plane, I was struck by the 1950s deco ambiance which jolts the traveler half-a-century back in time in just a few seconds.  The speakers played typical North Korean music which, at this point, was still charming.  The stewardesses made Donna Reid look like a street bum.  They served us a large meal and I drank some local beer called Ryongsong, which had a metalic after-taste.  It was definitely my least favorite of the DPRK brews as I came to find.  When the plane touched down in Pyongyang, the speakers welcomed us to the DPRK and told us about the Great Leader and the progress of the Juche Revolution.  Welcome to Pyongyang.

At Pyongyang’s Sunan Airport, we were escorted to a special VIP entrance, bypassing the baggage claim, customs and passport control desks.  This was so we could pose for pictures for the DPRK media and senior members of the KFA could give interviews, etc.  In the end it turned out to be kind of annoying because the airport people insisted that we go back through customs and passport control to retrieve our bags and come back through again, which was kind of a hassle because by that point we were behind everyone else in line.

         

   

   

The Sosan Hotel, our home.
KFA delegations primarily stay at the Sosan Hotel.  (There was one exception in 2005 for a large conference of groups sponsored by the CCRFC).  The Sosan is isolated in Pyongyang’s sports district and it was not build to cater to foreigners like the Potongang, Koryo, or Yangdakdo.  So when you are there, there is not much to do besides watch state television, drink, and chat with the same members of the group.  As I recall, the hotel is over 25 stories with more than 12 rooms on each floor.  Aside from our group there was just one other group of North Korean athletes staying there.

March For Peace and Unification
After settling in, Alejandro gave us some quick tips on how to “march,” something not all of us were too comfortable with and were not expecting.  I personally had not anticipated such public political activities, but in the end I though it was hysterical and indicative of the kinds of activities that many North Koreans have to participate in regularly.  There were several DPRK politicians there, including the head of the Committee for Cultural Relations with Foreign Countries.  The march took place at the Monument to the three charters of national reunification.

        

   

                

                

          

          

   

   

Sinchon
The March Continued in Sinchon, home to the Museum of American War Atrocities.  Although the Korean War is know as the “Forgotten War” in the United States, the citizens of the DPRK are reminded of it on a daily basis.  This museum plays a big part in that mission.  Next to the museum is a burial mound containing the victims of war atrocities. (This is much like the American War Atrocities Museum that used to be open in Hanoi)

*                **
*Get rid of the Americans and unite the nation
**Revenge on the American wolves 1000 times

          

          

 * 
*Long live the Workers Party of Korea

   

Sariwon-North Hawnghae Province
We then traveled to Sariwon to “work with the people”… By the time we arrived, I had been drinking and sitting around for so long that I was itching for some exercise.  So when it came to the heavy lifting, I was ready to go.  I pretty much smoked everyone else.  They were unable to compete with my pent up energy.  Chollima Speed, American style.

   

  

  

After KCNA completed their photos of the silly white-folks “working with the people,” we were treated to a great song and dance show. This was truly incredible.  Not to brag about myself, but the Dutch filmmakers who recorded this even told me I was a much better dancer than most of the other members of the group.  I have no idea of the name of the girl I was dancing with, but her look seems kind of haunting (in the pink dress below)…

   

                       

   *
*Our ideology, our style political system, our style revolutionary way!

Kaesong
After spending the night in Sariwon (near Sinchon), we were off to Kaesong for the next leg of the “March.”  Kaesong used to be in South Korea before the Korean War, and people there can pick up South Korean radio if they are clever enough.  The cheering crowd was composed of all the old women, non-working mothers, and children.  I did however (superficially) interacted with more Koreans than I thought would be possible, and got to walk down the main street in Kaesong. The march felt weird, but hey I was in the DPRK, and this is the kind of stuff they have to do all the time.  Imagine.

*   
*The girl with the bandana was a Russian translator.  She was trying to copy my sophisticated bandanna look.

         

   

   

Panmunjom
After walking down the street for another round of DPRK-style agitation, it was on to the last leg of the March in Panmunjom (the DMZ).  This was one of the highlights for me.  I have never visited South Korea, so my experience visiting the DMZ is exactly the opposite of most Americans.  I was thinking about holding a sign up that said “Hello from Arlington, VA” for my fellow countrymen on the other side.  Unfortunately no American soldiers were close enough to the border to talk to.  We had to listen to yet another round of political speeches here as well.  I was baking in the sun and could pretty much recite the speeches on my own.  You simply take the same 50 words and move them around.  It all gets repetitive pretty quickly.  Afterwards, the Koreans who were listening to it all took lost of pictures, and wanted several with me.  In the end this was an incredible experience and one I will never forget.  One thing the march did for me was bring home to me how sad it is that the Korean people are divided like this.

        

   

    

    

   

   

               

               

Kaesong
The Koryo Museum was kind of interesting and very pretty.  This museum is on the north-east side of Kaesong.

   

   

            

Tomb of Wanggon, founder of the Koryo Dynasty.

   

While in Kaesong, we stayed at the Folk Hotel.  Many people stay here, and as a result, most of the pictures of Kaesong that visitors post on the web look the same.  We visited a children’s palace there and saw a great show.  The children there were absolutely adorable and put on a very talented performance.

             

              

        

        

  * 
* Thank you Father kim Jong Il

        ***
*   We will honor the Great Leader Kim Il Sung as our eternal sun
** Lets become bullets and bombs protecting the Dear Leader Kim Jong Il

*  **
*  The Leader goes to the front line, and the children go to the camp
**Lets armor ourselves with Kim il Sung’s revolutionary ideas

   

                

   

Pakyon Waterfall
One of the most famous in the country.  It is truly beautiful and my pictures do not do it justice.  I was too busy having fun playing in the waterfall and throwing the Frisbee in the water to even explore the surroundings.

         

       

Back to Pyongyang

“Monument to Victory in Fatherland Liberation War”
The Fatherland Liberation War is the official name of the Korean war in the DPRK.  This site, next to the war museum, is a huge plaza with statues laid out symmetrically along the sides which depict specific stories that took place during the war–highlighting various acts of heroism by the Korean People’s Army.  The scale of the plaza or the size of the statue behind me is not accurately portrayed by the pictures.

       

   

       *        
*Lets destroy the American invaders

               

               *
*Unity of military and people

Pyongyang Metro
Most visitors to the Pyongyang metro visit the same two stops: from Ponghwa to Yonggwang (near the Koryo Hotel).
*         
* If the Americans attack us, let us destroy them off the earth forever

   

                

               

       

Kumsusan Memorial Palace
This is the mausoleum where Kim Il-sung is preserved in state like Lenin, Mao, and Ho Chi Minh.  I have seen all of these except “Uncle Ho” because he was in Russia getting touched up when I visited Hanoi.  Anyway, none of their facilities are nearly as complex and ornate as Kamsusan.  This building used to be Kim il Sung’s office, like the White (or blue) House.  Although plans were initially to bury Kim il Sung in Kim Il Sung Square, they decided to keep him in is office, since that “is where he spent all his time.”  Visitors to Kumsusan begin by checking any materials that they should not have, then they travel about a quarter of a mile by air conditioned moving sidewalk.   Along the way, you have the opportunity to clean your shoes and will also go through a metal detector.  At the end, you enter the first chamber playing the Song of Kim Il Sung.  Here you march in 4 person formation up to a large statue of the president in front of the room, upon which you are supposed to look at quietly for a few seconds.  Afterwards, you exit the room and go through a tunnel that blows air on you to remove any lint you might have, and then you are in the room with Kim il Sung himself.  You are supposed to bow respectfully on each side of his coffin.  The large tumor on the back of his neck has been removed.  After you exit the room, you observe the medals and awards Kim received from various nations and dictators.  You will also see his Mercedes, propped up on blocks, and his train cart.  After that you enter a room where a tour guide explains all of the great exploits of the leader.  Finally, you enter the last room where you can write something nice in the guest book.  It is illegal for south Koreans to visit here by South Korean law.

  *
* The Great Leader Kim Il Sung will always be with us

 *  
*Lets get “armed?” with Kim Il Sung, Revolutionary Leader

Taesongsan Revolutionary Martyrs Cemetery
This is the graveyard for Kim Il Sung’s guerrilla fighters that served with him in World War II, including his most famous wife, Jim Jong Suk, mother of Kim Jong Il.  It is also illegal for South Koreans to visit here by South Korean law.

         

          

*         
*Grave of Kim Jong Suk, mother of Kim Jong Il

         

Mangyongdae Funfair
Mangyongdae is where Kim Il Sung’s parents lived and he spent a lot of his childhood.  There is not much to it.  While we were there, the North Korean media were all over us.  I was never asked that much.  Afterwards we went to a nearby amusement park.  At first it was creepy as it was nearly deserted.  It seemed like we had discovered something that no one had seen in decades.  Eventually more people showed up in buses and livened the place up a bit.  There was a roller coaster there, but I gave it a pass.   It was fun to interact with all the children that showed up.  They got a kick out of playing “keep away” and posing for pictures with members of our group.

On a completely economic note, the fair seemed to operate a textbook two-part tariff pricing system.  This is when you pay an entrance fee to get in the park, but also a price per-ride.  This is a clever way for the provider to capture all of the “consumer surplus” of the visitor.

   

                

   *
*Amusement Hall

*         **
*  I don’t envy anyone
**Refreshment and drinks

   

        

Trip to Wonsan
We never had the opportunity to see much of Wonsan city itself.

 ***
*  Hail to the Great Leader Kim Jong Il
**Great integrity of mother party
 

Wonsan Childrens Camp
Empty but pretty fancy.  You can see this from Google Earth and you will also see that it is surrounded by some very nice houses.

   

          

Sijung Lake and beach
This was a nice beach/lake experience.  Just chillin’.

 * 
* Lets form ideology, technology, and culture in juche’s [way?]

                 

 

…then back to Pyongyang, and BOWLING!
Initially we asked to go bowling when we were bored in our hotel one night and we were told it was reserved for Koreans.  Then when an armistice day celebration was cancelled they decided to take us there.  Golden Lanes bowling alley, it turns out, has a “foreigners only” bathroom.

   

   

Mansu Hill
Korean visitors to Mansu Hill approach the statue in formation, bow and leave flowers.  They also stand looking at the statue while a giant speaker reads out exploits of the great leader.  I don’t know how long it lasted, but it was longer than I could pay attention.  This statue was initially coated in gold, but was removed after the Chinese threatened to reduce direct assistance.

         

                

    

                

          

Peoples’ Study House and Kim Il Sung Square
This is the large traditional style building that dominates Kim Il Sung square.  It offers language classes and meetings with specialists in various fields.  In a sense it offers some university-type services.

   

   

                  

   

*     **
*   Spirit of Pektu revolution
** Using the revoluitonary spirit of Pektu, build a strong great country

* *****
*Long Live the DPRK
**Long live the the honorable DPRK Workers Party
***The Great Leader Kim Il Sung will always be with us

   

   

Kimjongilia Flower Exhibition
How many politicians do you know that have flowers named after them?  Well the DPRK has two!  And both kinds are on display in a dedicated facility.

   

   

 

Arch of Triumph
The arch is supposed to be built on the site Kim Il Sung delivered his first speech after World War II.  Its big. Its an arch.

   

  

   

Moranbong Middle School
Moranbong was great.  We visited lots of classrooms, and while in in many classes the children did not look up from their notes, in others they were quite friendly and open.  I remember watching a girl take notes.  She wanted to look at the foreigner standing in front of her (me) by making repeating glances.  After realizing that I was just flat out looking at her without being coy enough to hide it in glances, she smiled and pulled half of her hand above the desk to wave at me without anyone else being able to see.  Priceless.

After touring the school and its numerous facilities, we were given another great performance by the school kids.  The incredible thing was that in the middle of the show, there was a power outage.  But they did not skip a beat.  They transitioned to an acoustic performance and opened up all the windows.  I felt bad for them, but they were professionals and took it all in stride.

*** 
* Lets become true children of father Kim Jong Il
** 100 wars, 100 victories, Korean Workers Party

*  **
*The Great Leader Kim Il Sung will always be with us
**Lets become youth heroes for fruitful struggle that ields the Kim Jong Il era

***      
* Lets learn from the Dear Leader Kim Jong Il honorable youth
**Get rid of the Americans and unite the motherland

      

         

 

Tower of Juche Idea
This is one of the most famous landmarks in Pyongyang.  The view is incredible.  Our visit was at the same time as some Chongryun dancers from Japan.

*            **
*The Great Leader Kim Il sung will always be with us
** Unity

        

        

   

   

   

Film Studio

   

   

Kochang Cooperative Farm
I did a lot of yard work here so I was sweating like a pig.  Although I had come to the DPRK expecting lots of propaganda, I was officially tired of it on this day.

Nampo
Nampo is on the west coast of Korea and home to the famous “Sea Barge” which prevents salt water from the sea from flowing up the fresh water Taedong River.  We spent a very stress-filled afternoon sitting on the beach wondering what was going to happen to Andrew.

   

Mangyongdae Children’s Palace

     

     

   

USS Pueblo
I was able to briefly recapture the Pueblo, but unsucessful at getting it out of Pyongyang.

         

   *
*this is a video of me on KCNA

Random Pyongyang Photos

*** 
*Pyongyang Metro station
** Let us inherit and complete the great work of the juche revolution

 *     **
*Famous Air Koryo hamburger (served on all outgoing flights)
** With Rifle, lets protect the socialist red flag

 *      
* May day stadium

***8**
*Lets keep our factory and workplace prudently
**Firm Protection
***Singe hearted unity

   

******
* Let us inherit and complete the great work of the juche revolution
**Lets become a fortress and shield protecting the revolutionary leaders
***Single hearted unity

* 
*Protect the Leader Kim Jong Il

***
*Hold the torch of Lenin and rush to build a strong and powerful nation
**Military service is the peoples divine obligation! Death to the enemies of unification!

**********
*Changwang street restaurants
**Koryo hotel
***Founding a strong great country is everlasting
****100 wars 100 victories

*    **
* Lets become a fortress and shield Pyongyang!
**Product learning and living all anti-Japanese squad style

 *
Billboard for thw whipperan, or “Whistle,” a fiat car made in the DPRK.

*** 
*Protect the leader Kim Jong Il
**These people are our heroes.  Lets be like them!& Lets accomplish what the party gives us!

* *Protect the leaders of the revolution!

Back in Beijing!

Welcome to the future home of NKeconWatch.com, the first blog that will be dedicated exclusively to analyzing the North Korean economy.  This sight has just been established and I am currently adding material and learning some basic web programming before the official launch.

If you have any suggestions or questions, please send email to: “NKeconWatch1@gmail.com” (and remove the “1”).

Thanks to Will Wilkinson for providing invaluable assistance in getting this project launched.

This web page was launched in January 2006 and since then it has been supported entirely by myself and some tech-savvy friends who have been generous enough to help with programming, organization, and technical issues.

Your donation is much appreciated by all who have made NKeconWatch.com a vibrant and comprehensive source for information on the DPRK!

Best,

Curtis

This web page is intended as a research resource for those who are gathering and publishing information on North Korea.  The editor of this site does not personally comment on many of the topics, unless the subject is something with which he has some first-hand experience. 

This site focuses on the North Korean economy (broadly defined), and does not dwell on foreign policy, human rights, military affairs, or defections.  These topics are thoroughly covered in other forums.  In a centrally-planned, highly-politicized economy like North Korea’s, it is difficult to separate political and economic analysis, but in such cases where separation is not possible, the editor’s comments will be expressed through the positive analysis of the Public Choice and New Institutional schools of economics.

If you agree or disagree with anything posted here, or simply have something to add that enriches other readers’ perspectives on any issue, please post your comments on the website.  The only thing the editor asks is that you post something intelligent and respectful.  Include citations to back up your claim(s) if possible. 

Five years down the line, the editor hopes this web site will be a popular source for discussion, research, publication, and general sharing of analysis on the North Korean economy. 

Finally, the editor extends an open invitation to scholars and business developers who specialize in North Korea to send any materials you wish to be posted on this site (many have already done so). This will save the editor time in finding your particular publication on line and will guarantee it is seen by the broader community of those interested in North Korean affairs. 

Please send materials, questions, and comments to the editor at NKeconWatch-(at)- gmail.com. 

About the Editor:
Curtis Melvin works in Arlington, Virginia, at the Mercatus Center at George Mason University, an organization which carries out a significant amount of research on entrepreneurship and institutional analysis in the developing world with an eye to understanding the institutional prerequisites that promote sustainable prosperity. 

Curtis has been interested in communist/socialist societies in general since he had the opportunity to visit the Soviet Union and several Warsaw Pact countries in his youth.  When traveling around the world in 1996 he picked up a Lonely Planet North East Asia guide book and got his first exposure to the DPRK.  In 2000 he began studying the country in earnest.  Thanks to opportunities offered by the  Korean Friendship Association, he was able to visit the DPRK in 2004 and 2005.

Curtis received his BBA in economics from the University of Georgia and MA in economics from George Mason University. 

Launched in January 2006, North Korean Economy Watch (NKeconWatch) is intended as a research resource for business persons, policy makers, academics, journalists and others interested in the North Korean economy (broadly speaking).

Creator/editor:

Curtis Melvin is a researcher at the US-Korea Institute at Johns Hopkins University and a contributor to 38 North.

Curtis enjoys traveling to developing nations. To date he has visited  over 50 countries including China, Zimbabwe, Iran, North Korea, Turkmenistan, and Myanmar. Curtis also enjoys Brazilian Jiu Jitsu, in which he is a purple belt.

Curtis received his BBA in economics from the University of Georgia and his MA in economics from George Mason University. He is ABD in the econ department at Geroge Mason University.

Co-editor:

Benjamin Katzeff Silberstein is a 2015 graduate of the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies in 2015 with an MA in international relations and international economics. He will begin his PhD in history at University of Pennsylvania in August 2015, focusing his research on North Korean political history.

Benjamin enjoys reading and writing about totalitarianism and the intersection between political oppression and economics. He previously worked in development politics for the Swedish government. He is an avid listener of the North Korean Army Choir.

Categories
The category menu on the right hand side of the web page links to relevant articles listed in order of posting.  The main categories are listed in alphabetical order, but the sub categories are listed under their relevant category heading.

This format might be confusing for new readers, so in instances where this is the case, please use the search box located at the top of the sidebar.

Additionally, confusion can arise over the proper romanization of Korean names.  In most cases, the categories are listed using the North Korean style of romanization (for instance, the editor uses “Kaesong” rather than “Gaeseong”).  However, when referencing another author’s work, the editor will leave in place the original author’s spelling.

Content
Content for this website is a combination of materials from outside sources and the editor’s own writings.  If the editor uses or posts someone else’s work, full credit will be given (and links if possible) so that said material may be verified and referenced by others.

This site focuses primarily on economic and cultural aspects of North Korea. This site does not generally focus on human rights issues or the nuclear issue, though they will come up from time to time. Although these topics are important, they are thoroughly covered in other forums.

Disclaimers
First, the views expressed by Curtis Melvin on this web site are his alone and should not be interpreted to to be those of any of his associates.

Secondly, there is a Twitter page for NKeconWatch. While I am appreciative of this page, I have no connection with it. This person is impersonating me.  Contacting or following that web page will not help you reach me. You can reach me at my personal Twitter account here or by email (see below).

Contributions
If you have specific knowledge which advances one of the topics being discussed in this forum, or you would like to put an item of interest to the readers of North Korean Economy Watch, the editor invites you to:

1. Post your comments for others to read on the related post. Citations would be much appreciated so others can cite your reference in later work.
2. Email stories and information directly to the editor of North Korean Economy Watch (as many already have) at: NKeconWatch “at” gmail “dot” com.
3. If you are interested in guest blogging or making regular contributions, please email the editor of this blog at the above address for more information.

Special projects:

Google Earth North Korea– Compiling public maps, interviews, innovative analysis, and elbow grease, the editor of this site has also created the most comprehensive mapping of North Korea that publicly exists today. You can download it onto Google Earth here. The next installment will be published with 38 North at the US-Korea Institute at Johns Hopkins SAIS.